“Old Flame” (* out of four) was a suffocating melodrama about two college friends (Rebecca Robles and Andy Gershenzon) who reunite over dinner but discover a dangerous and dark secret that they ruminate over and over and over again all night. Two-character story with two unlikeable characters who spout smarmy and stupid dialogue that rings completely false. Only the end carries any charge of surprise but good luck getting there; this monotonous mess grows “old” very soon.